After a castaway is voted out, they will pull one card from the deck. Two of the cards grant a single eliminated castaway immediate re-entry to the main game, while the other cards offer a variety of twists and choices that are unleashed onto the game once they are pulled. If a castaway draws a return card, they will immediately return to the game on the tribe of their choice (or the merged tribe). If they fail to draw a return card, they then go to Retribution Island where they will duel other eliminated castaways for the chance to draw more cards from the deck, or potentially win their way back into the game.
The twist ends once both return cards have been pulled.
|Zander K.||15||Rio Games Trivia selected as RI Duel. (won)|
|Zander K.||09||Double Tribal Council for one tribe.|
|Jack W.||13||Ethan H. Reward Duel for advantage. (lost)|
|Izaak Z.||02||Name That Logo! selected as main-game Immunity.|
|Jack W.||17||Color Trap selected as RI Duel. (won)|
|Tico F.||23||Tower Defence selected as main-game Immunity.|
|Jack W.||06||The Amazing Race selected as RI Duel.|
|Connor G.||14||Assign Power to Player|
The following cards were removed due to inactivity by card pullers: 16, 19, 21.